Internet Idol – just as bad as any other talent show

Over the weekend, Auckland’s ‘Q’ Theatre has seen (and is presumably still seeing) twenty-two candidates battling it out for fifteen places. It’s been dubbed ‘Political Idol’ or ‘Internet Idol’, which should perhaps leave a chill down the spin. Apparently, it’s been live-streamed (because they have the technology…), but given that I spent yesterday afternoon wielding a chainsaw (and, frankly, had many other better things to do, had I not been chainsawing), the only coverage I have seen was on 3News last night.

It wasn’t pretty, which was something the Internet Party should probably have expected. It’s all very well to go for transparency, in allowing cameras in to your giant selection meeting, but there’s a downside – the news media like comedy. You see it every year at the Green Party conference – the cameramen are sent off in search of the Morris Dancers, the most David Bain-esque cardigan and the Most Feral Beard. It stood to reason therefore that 3News wouldn’t be trying to show the prospective Internet Party candidates in their best light. We got a clip of an impromptu speech about paper cuts. We got a large, late-middle-aged lady trying to be impassioned (what was that about turning out the disillusioned youth vote?). We got Laila Harre showing us once again that she knows social justice, but not the internet. It was somewhat embarrassing.

Just check out the short list of twenty-two (link here). First up, you have Roshni Sami, aged 33, who’s been working in real estate for the past three years. I trust real estate agents slightly less than journalists. Next, there’s Raymond Calver, 36, social worker in lower decile schools – not a word in his bio about internet issues.

Sure, there are a few hopeful candidates with tech backgrounds, although they seem relatively few and far between. Frankly, most seem a little tragic, in a comic-gold sort of way. Take a look at Turi Te Kamonga, 42, whose “growing knowledge of crypto currencies offers a fresh outlook of monetary and fiscal policies”. “Together with a noticeable Political ambition, he shows promise for the requirements of a responsible candidate.” Good God.

There’s the Internet Party’s Social Media Engagement Manager, Callum Valentine, 26. Every candidate describes themselves at the start of their bio with three words. Mr Valentine’s are “Digital – Poliitcal – Citrus”. Citrus? WTF?

Speaking of strange choices for one’s three descriptive words, look no further than Timothy Kibblewhite, 22, who enigmatically wrote “Three is not…” An International Man of Mystery then…

At least Mr Kibblewhite could string three words together. Eli Weir, 39, missed the memo, using just two words – “Change Agent”. He’s one of those frightening sort of chaps who like ‘business speak’. He actually used the words “shifting paradigms” and “leveraging technology” in his bio…

And finally, there’s Bill Urale, better known as King Kapisi. His three words? “Tall – Samoan – Musician”. Inspiring stuff… If there’s one thing his presence on this list tells me, it’s that his music career is obviously no longer what it was.

The problem smaller parties face, especially smaller parties that are abruptly forming just prior to an election, is that the talent pool can be very small. Leaving aside the dedicated activists who put their hands up for parties like the Greens and Mana, small parties seem to end up with a ragtag collection of slightly deranged political opportunists. Just look at previous party lists for NZ First and United Future.

Anyhow, reading the candidate bios and watching the news footage felt like just another nail in the coffin of the Internet Mana Party’s intention to tap into that shadowy group of non-voters – the “Missing Million”.

Advertisements

4 comments

  1. I have blogged about their candidates social media pressence, or lack their off here, http://wp.me/p4jhfj-qP. Callum Valentine prides himself as the Social Media Manager, he apparently runs a social media agency with his partner, Spice Rack http://www.spicerack.net.nz, whose Twitter account has been going since something like August 2012 and has a whopping 192 followers. I haven’t really tried that hard to get followers and have over 900, 300 of which were gained in the last 3-4 months since I started blogging. The IP are a prime example of how you can claim to be a social media driven movement, when most of your exposure is coming from free mainstream media coverage.

    1. It was a sad day when they called time on their party… I fondly recall their transport policy – plant trees down the middle of every road in order to avoid head-on collisions between cars. The drove a car in each direction, on each side of a tree planted in the middle of a farm driveway, and whaddaya know, the cars didn’t collide head-on! Genius!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s