The Crimea situation

When Russian troops first took to the streets in the Crimean region of Ukraine, I made some predictions to my wife. I predicted that there would be a lot of talk from the US, Europe and assorted other Western allies, but little else. The United Nations would make a resolution that the situation should be resolved by diplomatic means. America would bluster, and little else. Meanwhile, Russia would maintain its troop presence, Ukraine’s troops would fire nary a shot in anger, and the Crimea would end up being annexed to Russia almost by default, as international attention eventually moved on.

Well, I was partly right. The UN has, as usual, been all talk, and sometimes not even that. Russian troops are staying put. Ukrainian and Russian troops haven’t yet ended up in battle. Many countries have expressed their disappointment and regret at Russia’s actions, and Russia doesn’t give a toss.

Admittedly, I didn’t see the referendum coming. Whether it’s a good move or not by Russia remains to be seen. It may very well end up being a flashpoint, something that concentrates Ukraine’s mind on the imminent loss of the Crimea and sparks a reaction. Prior to the referendum being announced, the situation could have drifted on indefinitely, with Russian occupation becoming the default setting. With a referendum about to occur, with a pro-Russian outcome being a dead cert due to a lack of a pro-Ukraine option, Ukraine may see the use of force as the only viable solution to keep the Crimea. Whether that’s Ukraine’s ragtag reservist army that’s been rapidly formed, or informal pro-Ukraine militias, remains to be seen.

There will probably be violence, but I doubt the Ukrainian government is foolish enough to risk full-scale war with Russia. There’s now no credible way for Ukraine to keep the Crimea, and Ukraine must surely know that. Any violence will be from pro-Ukrainian protests that turn ugly. Unfortunately for those protesters, Russia is very good at putting down such protests in a quick and brutal manner…



  1. I suspect that this will be a battle lost by Ukraine, but the longer term war may be lost by Putin. He has started to block access to opposition news sites in Russia, and there have been anti-war protests in Moscow. So he may win the battle, but I suspect he will loose the war.

    1. I’d have thought it would take a serious surge in the level of protest action within Russia to seriously trouble Putin. He’s weathered a fair few widespread protest actions over the years… As long as the Ukrainian military don’t attack the Russians and spark a full-scale war in the Crimea, I can’t see the anti-war protests in Russia getting much oxygen for too long.

      Mind you, I wasn’t aware that Putin was blocking opposition news sites, so perhaps he’s starting to get more worried than usual…

      1. I saw the report of news sites getting blocked coming from Garry Kasparov, who has also had his web admins contacted asking them to turn their servers off.

        Trying to blog media sites is always the first resort of
        despots, but never turns out well.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s